Rising Menace of False Rape Cases in India
Problems and Solutions
The menace of false rape cases has been rising since the amendment of rape laws in 2013 in India.
This trend is evident from the judgments of fast-track courts across the country, including Delhi,
and from various news reports. Early checks on this issue are necessary to prevent the misuse of
laws and to protect the social fabric.
A news report highlighted the rise in false rape cases in Punjab within a week after the Delhi
gang rape case. It mentioned that a woman, accused of injecting a child with an HIV-infected
needle, was granted bail while another youth involved was denied bail. This reflects the potential
misuse of laws introduced post-2013 to protect women, which are being exploited in some instances.
Case Laws:
Illustration 1:
A woman falsely claimed she was kidnapped and gang-raped to implicate her boyfriend's wife,
who had accused her of attempted murder. The case also involved consensual sexual relations
between the woman and her accomplice to fabricate evidence. The suspects were charged under
various sections of the Indian Penal Code, including cheating, submitting false evidence, and
criminal conspiracy.
Illustration 2:
A divorced woman accused a man of rape after he did not fulfill his promise to marry her.
The accused argued that their relationship was consensual and based on mutual understanding.
The Bombay High Court noted no prima facie evidence of rape and granted pre-arrest bail to
the accused, observing that the case appeared to be motivated by personal vendetta.
Illustration 3:
An elderly man, aged 75, was falsely accused of rape and spent six months in jail before being
acquitted. The court highlighted the fabricated nature of the allegations, which were intended to
usurp the accused's property. The case emphasized the devastating impact of false allegations
on an individual's dignity and mental well-being.
Consequences and Role of Media:
False rape allegations cause irreparable damage to the accused, including social isolation, loss of
reputation, and mental trauma. Media plays a crucial role in shaping public opinion, but it often
focuses on accusations while ignoring acquittals, perpetuating stigma against the falsely accused.
Solutions:
1. Compensation: Courts should consider awarding compensation to those acquitted of false
rape charges to help them rebuild their lives.
2. Perjury Cases: Legal action should be taken against individuals who fabricate evidence or
make false accusations.
3. Awareness Campaigns: Society, activists, and media must work together to raise awareness
about the consequences of false rape allegations and promote the responsible use of legal provisions.
In conclusion, addressing the issue of false rape cases requires a collective effort from the legal
system, society, and media to ensure justice for both actual victims and the falsely accused.
Mrunmay M. Pote.
No comments:
Post a Comment